Showing posts with label Art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Art. Show all posts
11.9.09
An amazing bit of creative art
I was randomly browsing the internet and I came across this website of a guy who does some pretty spectacular work with paper. I'm impressed.
4.9.09
The end of the rant
Well, here we are at the end. Congratulations to everyone who is still reading.
Problem 9: Cultural stigma against real art
Problem 9: Cultural stigma against real art
I read an article for a class of mine that has something to do with this subject. Essentially, the articles expresses the idea that many people consider something good as long as it doesn't have anything even remotely objectionable in it, and they consider something bad when there is anything slightly objectionable in it. Unfortunately, many of the world's greatest works of art include material that might offend some people. What we need is the ability to glean something of value from a work even if there are things we don't agree with. Of course there are limits. We don't want to be viewing things that are openly pornographic or things that don't exercise any sense of restraint, but otherwise we should approach things with some toleration.
Let me give you an example (the same one used in the article in case you decided to skip it): Shakespeare. Most people will agree that his work is one of the great pinnacles of literature. Shakespeare was lovingly carried across the plains by pioneers who could bring precious little art and culture with them. We revere the work that he did and quote it often in church or general conference, yet Shakespeare is filled with dirty jokes, violence, witchcraft, and mounds of other vulgar and profane things. But that doesn't change the fact that his work can touch profound and sublime things in all of us. Shakespeare is therefore great art, in spite of the portions of his work that some would find objectionable.
Essentially I am saying that we need reasonable vigilance against damaging material in art, but that we shouldn't throw something good out because of some small offense.
Problem 10: Assumption that LDS-themed art is bad
I'm as guilty of this as anyone. When I hear about a new play based on the Book of Mormon, I assume that it's going to be bad. When someone writes a new piece of music about the Gospel, I usually don't go to see it because I don't want to be embarrassed by its low quality. The same goes for painting and books and all the other arts. Some of that response is conditioned by repeated disappointments, but it is exactly that kind of conditioned response that we need to guard against. In other words, give LDS artists a chance. Someday they'll create something great. A few already have.
If you want to read a little more about LDS art and artists, go here.
Here, here, here, and here are a few artist who I think are doing a great job, right now.
Well, that's the end of my rant. As a disclaimer I reserve the right to change my mind about any or all of the things I have written at any time, without notice. That is all.
2.9.09
Coming into the home stretch here
It's the halfway point on my multi-week rant, so let's dive right in.
Problem 6: Unrealistic views of life and the human condition
My view on this particular issue is changing around somewhat. On the one hand, we tend to be a more positive and optimistic group of people than most. Some, even in the church, would say that we're just fooling ourselves. If we lived in the real world we'd know what it was really like and we'd know how terrible everything is.
Bull.
I watched an interview with President Packer, and he made some terrific points. I kept thinking that he was in trouble with some of the questions that he was being asked, but his responses were terrific. In answer to a similar question that was raised (I apologize for the paraphrasing, but I don't have a transcript of it) he said, "It's our responsibility to represent things as they ought to be, not as they are." He went on to say essentially that it was good and wonderful and important to deal with difficult subjects, but you can do it in a way that's tasteful. You can portray things in such a way that it is clear what has gone on, but that doesn't offend the spirit. As far as our world-view goes, assuming that our theology (or really almost anyone's theology) is true, and I believe that ours is, then a positive, upbeat outlook on life is the proper one.
Problem 7: No market for quality work
As I've pondered this, I don't think it's the issue. People want quality work, they often just don't know how to distinguish it. For instance, if all you've ever seen is a light bulb, then you can't conceive of how bright and illuminating the sun it. In the same way, we have many members who've rarely seen truly great, or even truly good art. If they had, then much of the problem would be non-existent I believe.
Problem 8: Intolerance for "black sheep" in the LDS community
The beautiful thing about the gospel is how broad and inclusive it is. So much of it is left up to our own personal judgement that it can be easy to look askance at those who choose differently than you do on some of those grey areas. Beyond just small things, it's even more difficult for those who struggle with major issues, but still try and remain worthy. Let me give you an example: I attend BYU as a music major. For some reason, the arts tend to attract people with homosexual tendencies. Even at BYU, many of my good friends struggle with same-sex attraction. They're good people and some of the most talented students that we have at the school, but they're under almost a don't ask/don't tell type of policy. Officially they're welcome to attend BYU as long as they maintain the standards like anyone else, but they often deal with persecution and ostracization from so-called Christians who find out about them. Prejudice like that is unacceptable. The quickest way to kill the arts is to start making life difficult for those who don't fit the perfect normal mold.
I don't want this to be just a rant on accepting people who struggle with sin. I have friends who felt like they were resented by some members of their congregation simply because they drank caffeine or watched r-rated movies or had some odd hobby. Whether or not you think that those things are sins, there are surely better causes that you can put your time into than stamping out Pepsi and Coke's presence in Utah. Just remember that we as a people need to be more tolerant and loving overall, and less rigid, judgemental, and exclusive.
Problem 6: Unrealistic views of life and the human condition
My view on this particular issue is changing around somewhat. On the one hand, we tend to be a more positive and optimistic group of people than most. Some, even in the church, would say that we're just fooling ourselves. If we lived in the real world we'd know what it was really like and we'd know how terrible everything is.
Bull.
I watched an interview with President Packer, and he made some terrific points. I kept thinking that he was in trouble with some of the questions that he was being asked, but his responses were terrific. In answer to a similar question that was raised (I apologize for the paraphrasing, but I don't have a transcript of it) he said, "It's our responsibility to represent things as they ought to be, not as they are." He went on to say essentially that it was good and wonderful and important to deal with difficult subjects, but you can do it in a way that's tasteful. You can portray things in such a way that it is clear what has gone on, but that doesn't offend the spirit. As far as our world-view goes, assuming that our theology (or really almost anyone's theology) is true, and I believe that ours is, then a positive, upbeat outlook on life is the proper one.
Problem 7: No market for quality work
As I've pondered this, I don't think it's the issue. People want quality work, they often just don't know how to distinguish it. For instance, if all you've ever seen is a light bulb, then you can't conceive of how bright and illuminating the sun it. In the same way, we have many members who've rarely seen truly great, or even truly good art. If they had, then much of the problem would be non-existent I believe.
Problem 8: Intolerance for "black sheep" in the LDS community
The beautiful thing about the gospel is how broad and inclusive it is. So much of it is left up to our own personal judgement that it can be easy to look askance at those who choose differently than you do on some of those grey areas. Beyond just small things, it's even more difficult for those who struggle with major issues, but still try and remain worthy. Let me give you an example: I attend BYU as a music major. For some reason, the arts tend to attract people with homosexual tendencies. Even at BYU, many of my good friends struggle with same-sex attraction. They're good people and some of the most talented students that we have at the school, but they're under almost a don't ask/don't tell type of policy. Officially they're welcome to attend BYU as long as they maintain the standards like anyone else, but they often deal with persecution and ostracization from so-called Christians who find out about them. Prejudice like that is unacceptable. The quickest way to kill the arts is to start making life difficult for those who don't fit the perfect normal mold.
I don't want this to be just a rant on accepting people who struggle with sin. I have friends who felt like they were resented by some members of their congregation simply because they drank caffeine or watched r-rated movies or had some odd hobby. Whether or not you think that those things are sins, there are surely better causes that you can put your time into than stamping out Pepsi and Coke's presence in Utah. Just remember that we as a people need to be more tolerant and loving overall, and less rigid, judgemental, and exclusive.
31.8.09
Further Rumiations on LDS Art
I only have enough time to explore two of the possible problems that I mentioned earlier, so here we go.
As far as your religious faith is concerned, you'll be fine if you take what the prophets say and pattern your life accordingly, but art needs to have questions, issues, insights, conflicts, doubts, triumphs, and failures. I don't want to say that there isn't depth in our ideas and feelings, but for great works to be produced, there has to be more thought put into the gospel than what I often see on Sunday.
On a side note as I hit the half-way point here, I don't want anyone reading this to think that I'm in any way criticizing the church, the gospel, or any of the Lord's anointed leaders. The church is God's only true church on the earth, the Gospel is the Truth the Christ came to bring us, and the leaders of the church are what they claim to be: prophets, the Lord's mouthpiece on the Earth. What I am criticizing is the prevailing culture of LDS people accepting gospel-themed mediocrity as art.
Problem 4: Not enough education and training of artists
This one could be looked at in several different ways. On the one hand, are some extremely well-trained artists who are LDS. But on the other hand, that level of training is the exception, not the rule. You can argue that BYU and the other church schools have enormous numbers of applicants to their fine arts programs, so clearly there is an interest, but quantity doesn't equal quality, and our programs continue to be sort-of mid-range as far as their quality. For me, I think this is a problem for one reason: the evidence of supply and demand. There is a market for the huge amount of banality peddled by Deseret Book and its imitators. To at least some degree that market is fueled by people who don't know or don't care that something themed around the Book of Mormon is not necessarily created with care, quality, or artistry. If we as a people were better versed in the arts and culture, then we'd be better able to recognize those who try to profit off of our devotion to the gospel without adding anything to it.
This one could be looked at in several different ways. On the one hand, are some extremely well-trained artists who are LDS. But on the other hand, that level of training is the exception, not the rule. You can argue that BYU and the other church schools have enormous numbers of applicants to their fine arts programs, so clearly there is an interest, but quantity doesn't equal quality, and our programs continue to be sort-of mid-range as far as their quality. For me, I think this is a problem for one reason: the evidence of supply and demand. There is a market for the huge amount of banality peddled by Deseret Book and its imitators. To at least some degree that market is fueled by people who don't know or don't care that something themed around the Book of Mormon is not necessarily created with care, quality, or artistry. If we as a people were better versed in the arts and culture, then we'd be better able to recognize those who try to profit off of our devotion to the gospel without adding anything to it.
Problem 5: No depth of thought among our people
This is a thorny issue. If my blog had more that five or ten readers, it could get me into trouble. I worry that deep thinking, while not discouraged, is not always held up as a virtue in LDS culture. Many of the prophets were deep thinkers who spent hours pondering on the scriptures, but we, being the beneficiaries of their intellectual and spiritual legacies, are often given so many astounding answers and insights that we don't bother to think more deeply about issues. When you get the meaning of life laid out for you on a platter when you're five or six years old, it's hard to figure out where to go from there.As far as your religious faith is concerned, you'll be fine if you take what the prophets say and pattern your life accordingly, but art needs to have questions, issues, insights, conflicts, doubts, triumphs, and failures. I don't want to say that there isn't depth in our ideas and feelings, but for great works to be produced, there has to be more thought put into the gospel than what I often see on Sunday.
On a side note as I hit the half-way point here, I don't want anyone reading this to think that I'm in any way criticizing the church, the gospel, or any of the Lord's anointed leaders. The church is God's only true church on the earth, the Gospel is the Truth the Christ came to bring us, and the leaders of the church are what they claim to be: prophets, the Lord's mouthpiece on the Earth. What I am criticizing is the prevailing culture of LDS people accepting gospel-themed mediocrity as art.
28.8.09
Even more on LDS Art
I'm going to take the first few things I mentioned in the last post and examine their validity. Assuming that they're valid, I'll go ahead and offer a possible solution or two. I figure that it's easy to see problems with something; the real trick is finding effective solutions.
Problem 1: Lack of inherent talent among our people
Anyone who thinks that this "problem" is a legitimate one hasn't read President Kimball's talk or doesn't know that he's a prophet.
"As I have traveled throughout the Church, many times I have been entranced with sweet and lovely voices. I believe that deep in the throats of these faithful Saints of today and tomorrow are superior qualities which, superbly trained, can be equal or surpass these known great singers.
"Members of the Church should be peers or superiors to any others in natural ability, extended training, plus the Holy Spirit which should bring them light and truth. With hundreds of 'men of God' and their associates so blessed, we have the base for an increasingly efficient and worthy corps of talent."
Natural talent shouldn't be the issue with the poor quality work being turned out.
Problem 2: Lack of focus on the arts
This problem is actually a problem. Colleges want generalists, society wants specialists. Unfortunately, many LDS kids choose to explore a multitude of hobbies and activities, but choose to excel in none of them. Parents justify this behavior to themselves saying that their child is just trying to find something that they like, but the reality is that most kids are just trying to find something that comes easily to them or trying to pad their college applications. Once something becomes hard or something is expected of them they switch to their new interest. They're not doing themselves or anyone else any favors.
If we want great artists then we have let people specialize. The day of the Renaissance Man is long past. It's time for the specialist to take over.
Problem 3: Few full-time professional artists in the church
I'm not advocating that the church suddenly start hiring artists full time, but that practice has been a major contributing factor to the rich tradition of art in the Catholic church. Artistic greatness is rarely achieved by those who work towards it in their spare time. There also seems to be a general feeling in the church that professional artists are unable to keep their standards, so many who would lean in that direction shy away from it.
Here's the reality: you will find dishonest, immoral, evil people in any profession that you choose. Just because the art community tends to flaunt it more openly doesn't mean that you're safe from ethical and moral challenges just because you've decided to be an accountant. If you do the things that you need to do in order to stay close to the church and keep your testimony, then you'll be fine no matter what profession you choose. If you don't then you'll have problems no matter what proffession you choose.
Well, that's a quick look at the first three of the ten problems that I mentioned. I'll get to the rest in the next few posts.
26.8.09
More on LDS Art
If you're going to examine LDS art at this point, the place to start is with Spencer W. Kimball. He gave what is essentially the landmark address on LDS art and artists. You can read it here. In fact, you should read it. Go read it. Now. Done? Okay good. For the majority of LDS artists of the day, this became a major part of their inspiration/vision. I know at least one of my teachers who completely changed his career path so that he could help fulfill in some small measure this vision.
This talk is also heavily emphasized in many of the classes that I've taken, so most people of my generation are pretty familiar with it as well. I want to look at the talk and (working from a position of belief that the prophet is in fact a prophet) examine what possible issues are holding LDS art back, and what can be done about them.
I took a few minutes and jotted down several actual or potential issues with LDS art:
1. Lack of inherent talent among our people
2. Lack of focus on the arts
3. Few full-time professional artists in the church
4. Not enough education and training of artists
5. No depth of thought among our people
6. Unrealistic views of life and the human condition
7. No market for quality work
8. Intolerance for "black sheep" in the LDS community
9. Cultural stigma against real art
10. Assumption that LDS-themed art is bad
I could obviously stretch this discussion into a lot of posts, but I'll try and limit it to three or four. And of course, if you have anything to add, feel free to comment.
24.8.09
LDS Art
So, I've been thinking about a conversation that I had with a friend of mine many years ago. It centered on the fact that, aside from a few notable examples, there was a whole bunch of terrible LDS art (by art I mean anything that could pass as one of the fine arts). She's a painter and I'm an opera singer, and we both see a serious lack of quality LDS work being done in our respective fields. We decided to do what we could to create a renaissance of LDS culture, so here's my call for an LDS renaissance. I want to see some quality work done. No kitsch, nothing vulgar or unclean. Put all your creativity and craft into it.
For the next few posts I'm going to be talking about what the problems are and what we can do to fix them. We'll see how it goes. I'm not guaranteeing any conclusions about anything, since most writers agree that what you think about a subject changes as you write about it. I suppose writing is an essential key to lucid thought. Anyway, we'll see where we go.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)